Category: Pests & Algae | Keywords: cyanobacteria reef tank, red slime algae | In short: Red slime is not an alga but a photosynthetic bacterium, and it blooms when conditions in the tank favour it: rising nutrients and dissolved organics, dead spots with detritus, and sometimes light. A zero on the phosphate test does not guarantee safety. The durable fix is to siphon the mats out, find and correct the cause, improve flow and keep up maintenance. Donowitz treats antibiotic-based products as a last resort; Bulk Reef Supply says they work but do not stop the problem returning.
This is an update of our 2023 post on cyanobacteria. We have re-read the sources, kept only what they actually support, and added what the research on real reefs can (and cannot) tell us about tanks.
What “red slime algae” really is
The name is misleading. As Randy Donowitz put it in Advanced Aquarist, what we call red slime algae is a form of cyanobacteria, a bacterial life form that, like algae, contains chlorophyll and photosynthesises. In his words it is “neither algae, nor is it always red”: patches can be green, brown, black or red, and they almost always show the air bubbles that betray photosynthesis [1]. Bulk Reef Supply likewise describes it as a photosynthetic bacterium and notes that it exists in all aquariums and only grows prolifically when conditions are right for it [2].
That last point matters. Donowitz says cyanobacteria are present in all marine systems and are often visible as small patches even in healthy ones, and it is not uncommon for limited growth to develop in low-current areas behind the rockwork, on internal plumbing, or at the base of some leather corals. A small patch is not a reason to panic, but it is a reason to watch and to test [1].
If you want a quick, non-aquarium introduction to these organisms, these two general-biology videos are a good start (they are about cyanobacteria in nature, not about reef tanks):
Why they bloom
Nutrients and dissolved organics
Donowitz states that outbreaks are “almost always tied to an increase in dissolved organics” and recommends testing phosphate (PO4) and nitrate (NO3) whenever new patches appear. If they are rising, he asks the obvious questions: are we overfeeding, keeping up with water changes, using contaminated source water, did something die, is the tank overstocked? [1]. Reef Builders gives a similar list: blooms occur when nitrate, phosphate and dissolved organic compounds get too high, with weak skimming, too many fish or too much food, infrequent water changes, uncured live rock and nutrient-laden source water or additives as contributing factors [3].
Cyanobacteria are also well equipped for this. According to Donowitz they can pull dissolved organic compounds directly from the substrate and the water column, which helps them thrive across a wide range of conditions [1]. For background on both sides of this, see our articles on managing nutrients, phosphate and dissolved organic matter, and on the N:P ratio.
“But my phosphate test reads zero”
This is the most common objection, and the sources suggest the test result is not the whole story. Bulk Reef Supply reports having seen cyanobacteria grow in reef tanks with 0 phosphate and 0 nitrate, and recommends aiming for balance rather than elimination: phosphate above zero but below 0.10 ppm, and nitrate below 5 ppm [2].
Why might nutrients be present yet invisible in the water sample? Research on wild reefs offers a plausible mechanism, with an important caveat: it comes from coral reefs, not aquariums, so we treat it as an analogy and not as proof about your tank. In a survey around Curaçao, Brocke and colleagues found that nutrient concentrations in the open water were consistently low, but increased markedly just above substrata covered by benthic cyanobacterial mats. Their interpretation is that mat growth is stimulated by a localised release of nutrients from organic matter that has settled on the seafloor: its degradation creates an anoxic zone at the sediment surface, and organic matter keeps accumulating under the mat, driving further growth. In an in situ experiment, mats grew within days on sediments enriched with organic matter (Spirulina) [4]. A review of benthic cyanobacterial mats adds that, when sediments turn anoxic, iron reduction can release phosphate and iron, and that where sediments contain iron, mat growth can be stimulated. The review is explicit that these drivers are “putative”, not fully proven [5].
Donowitz makes the aquarium-side version of the same point: as a reef system ages (he says this of veterans whose husbandry slips), dissolved nutrients begin to accumulate in the rock and the sand bed, providing ideal conditions for cyanobacteria [1]. Putting these together, a reasonable working hypothesis is that a clean-looking water sample can coexist with nutrient-rich detritus and sediment right where the mat sits. That is an inference from the sources, not something any of them measured in a home aquarium.
Low flow and detritus
Bulk Reef Supply notes that cyanobacteria seem to grow in areas of low water flow and high detritus build-up [2], and Reef Builders says it favours slack water and has a hard time gaining a foothold where circulation is brisk [3]. The reef data fit this: the Curaçao authors propose that organic matter is transported by currents and settles on the seabed at sites with low hydrodynamics [4]. Our guide to flow covers how to plan circulation; for this problem the key idea is simply that detritus should not be allowed to settle and stay.
Light
Donowitz notes there is “a lot of anecdotal evidence” that light spectrum and intensity play a role, which is unsurprising given how broadly cyanobacteria photosynthesise. Lamps shift in spectrum and lose intensity over the months, so it is worth ruling out, but in his experience lighting is usually not the main culprit [1]. Bulk Reef Supply also says an improper light spectrum could spark an outbreak, more so in the days of T5 fluorescent lighting [2]. We would treat light as a secondary factor to check, not as the first suspect.
Young tanks and neglected tanks
Here it is easy to over-generalise, so we report Donowitz precisely. He writes that it is quite common for cyanobacteria to bloom during the initial months of a system’s life, because of the elevated dissolved organics produced by curing live rock combined with an immature filtration system. During this period, he says, it is rare to see red cyanobacteria, and the green or brown varieties that commonly develop seem to recede of their own accord as the system matures. He advises stocking slowly, since a too rapid introduction of nitrogenous waste greatly increases the chance of a severe outbreak [1]. In other words: an early green or brown film may fade as the tank matures, but that is not a licence to ignore a red mat.
The same author says the aquarists most susceptible to outbreaks are beginners who do not know better and seasoned veterans whose husbandry slips [1].
Why it is worth stopping early
Left unchecked, Donowitz says it is always a problem: mats can spread over sand, rock and in severe cases corals themselves, and he documents a stony coral damaged by unabated growth [1]. The reef literature adds that mats are reported to release high amounts of dissolved organic carbon, a reinforcing feedback, and that they directly impair coral recruitment, although the DOC finding rests on a single Curaçao study cited in the review [5].
How to stop them, sustainably
1. Find the cause first
Test phosphate and nitrate, then work through the checklist above: feeding, water change routine, source water, stocking, dead organisms [1]. Change the RO/DI resins if in doubt; Donowitz suggests doing so during a bloom to ensure the purest possible water for exchanges and top-off [1], and Reef Builders likewise recommends RO or RO/DI water [3].
2. Remove the mats mechanically
Bulk Reef Supply calls physical removal the most important step: siphon the mats out, every day if needed, and expect to lose some water, so a water exchange has to follow. They suggest catching the debris in a filter sock on the siphon hose and returning the filtered water to the tank [2]. Donowitz adds practical details: siphon off as much as possible, scrub easily removable rocks in a separate container, and remove the pockets of detritus found near or under the mats, for instance by blowing detritus off the substrate with a turkey baster or small powerhead so the mechanical filter can catch it. Donowitz notes that mats trap oxygen bubbles that eventually lift them off the substrate; on recurring patches that threaten no other organism he lets them thicken for a while so they lift off intact and are easy to remove [1]. If a mat is siphoned off a coral it is attacking, the coral may be saved [1].
The video above, from Bulk Reef Supply’s channel, shows tools for tackling red slime; we recommend watching it for the practical side of removal.
3. Water changes and export
Donowitz recommends that, if an outbreak is caught early, a series of partial water exchanges with RO/DI water and a good-quality salt mix will usually do the trick; for an established bloom he proposes bi-weekly 25-30% changes combined with thorough siphoning (his “bi-weekly” is ambiguous; testing and stability matter more than the exact interval) [1]. See our piece on water changes. He also advises checking that the protein skimmer is clean and functioning properly (and upgrading it if undersized), cleaning the circulation pumps, and siphoning appreciable detritus out of the sump [1]. His 2005 text goes on to suggest frequent carbon changes, iron-based phosphate-removal media and kalkwasser; since that is dated, optional advice, we mention it for completeness and recommend weighing it against our phosphate guide and the “do not strip to zero” caveat above [1][2]. Kalkwasser and phosphate-removal media can cause pH, alkalinity or phosphate swings if overdone, so introduce them only gradually, with testing.
4. Fix dead spots
Reef Builders recommends adding or redirecting powerheads to eliminate dead spots [3], and Donowitz suggests upgrading circulation to eliminate dead spots and prevent detritus from accumulating on the substrate [1]. Look specifically at where the mat started: Donowitz notes that limited growth is not uncommon in low-current areas behind the rockwork and on internal plumbing [1].
5. Keep nutrients balanced, not zero
Bulk Reef Supply’s advice is prevention first: balanced nutrients, flow, regular cleaning of sand bed and rock, and stable temperature and chemistry. They also mention adding copepods and amphipods to build a more diverse ecosystem that competes with cyanobacteria [2].
6. Let the cleanup crew help, within limits
Donowitz notes that very few animals eat cyanobacteria, though some reef-safe snails and hermit crabs will, as will queen conch and some sea hares. They help prevent a bloom taking hold but will not eradicate a full outbreak [1]. Use caution: large or short-lived animals can create their own problems in a reef tank.
7. Be patient
Donowitz warns that persistence is paramount, as reversing a bloom may take weeks or even months [1]. Reef Builders says it may take several months to turn the tide [3].
What does not work (or not on its own)
- Treating the symptom only. Bulk Reef Supply says chemical cyano treatments do work but will not prevent the cyanobacteria from coming back [2].
- Relying on antibiotics. In his 2005 text, Donowitz notes that most red slime products contain antibiotics such as erythromycin that, in his words, do not discriminate between types of bacteria, so you lose some of the good along with the bad, and that bacteria quickly become resistant, so later treatment may be less effective. He calls this a last resort that can be avoided by following the steps above [1]. Bulk Reef Supply, by contrast, describes current reef-safe treatments as killing cyanobacteria without harming the beneficial bacteria [2]; the two sources disagree, so read the label of any product. If you do use a chemical treatment, Bulk Reef Supply says these products can lower oxygen levels, so an airstone is needed, since the skimmer must be turned off to avoid removing the medication; afterwards the product is removed with carbon and water changes, and they always recommend siphoning the mats before and after treatment, and following the manufacturer’s directions exactly [2].
- Chasing zero nutrients. Cyanobacteria have been seen in tanks with 0 phosphate and 0 nitrate [2].
- Counting on the cleanup crew alone [1].
- Blaming the lights first. Possible, but usually not the main culprit [1].
- Expecting a quick win. This is a weeks-to-months job [1][3].
FAQ
Is red slime algae actually algae?
No. It is cyanobacteria, a photosynthetic bacterium, and it is not always red [1][2].
Is a bloom in a brand-new tank normal?
Donowitz says blooms are common in the initial months because of the dissolved organics from curing live rock and an immature filtration system, but that during this period red cyanobacteria is rare, and it is the green or brown forms that tend to recede as the system matures. Slow stocking helps [1]. It does not mean that every film can be ignored.
My phosphate and nitrate read zero. Why do I still have cyano?
Bulk Reef Supply has seen cyano with both at zero [2]. Reef research suggests nutrients can be released locally from organic matter under the mat even when the surrounding water is low [4]. Detritus (including in the sand bed and rockwork) and dead spots are worth checking [1][2].
Can corals be harmed?
Yes. Donowitz describes mats covering corals and damage to a stony coral from unabated growth [1]. A review of reef mats reports they impair coral recruitment [5].
Should I use erythromycin or a red slime remover?
Only as a last resort, according to Donowitz, who points to collateral loss of beneficial bacteria and resistance [1]. Fix the cause first, and if you do use a product, follow Bulk Reef Supply’s oxygen precautions [2].
How long will it take?
Plan on weeks to months of consistent work [1][3].
References
- Donowitz R. “Did I Say That: Algae By Any Other Name.” Advanced Aquarist, republished on Reefs.com, 17 March 2015 (originally Marine Fish and Reef USA Annual, 2005). https://reefs.com/magazine/did-i-say-that-algae-by-any-other-name/
- Bulk Reef Supply. “How to Prevent and Remove Cyanobacteria From Your Aquarium – Help! I Wrecked My Tank Ep. 5.” https://www.bulkreefsupply.com/content/post/md-2019-02-red-slime-reef-tank-pest-control
- Kurtz J. “BGA Battle Plan: Controlling Cyanobacteria in Saltwater Aquariums.” Reef Builders, 15 July 2013. https://reefbuilders.com/2013/07/15/controlling-cyanobacteria-blue-green-algae-rid-aquarium
- Brocke HJ, Polerecky L, de Beer D, Weber M, Claudet J, Nugues MM. “Organic matter degradation drives benthic cyanobacterial mat abundance on Caribbean coral reefs.” PLoS ONE 10(5): e0125445 (2015). https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0125445
- Ford AK, Bejarano S, Nugues MM, Visser PM, Albert S, Ferse SCA. “Reefs under Siege—the Rise, Putative Drivers, and Consequences of Benthic Cyanobacterial Mats.” Frontiers in Marine Science 5:18 (2018). https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/marine-science/articles/10.3389/fmars.2018.00018/full